Consumers nearly everywhere are aware of the brands Neutrogena and Oil of Olay. In the world of supermarket/drugstore beauty products, they are in the upper echelon. They are, in a way, the Chanel and Lancôme of Rite Aid and Walmart. While not exorbitantly priced (like Chanel and Lancôme), they are still not cheap. But, according to a plastic surgeon — as well as other experts – Neutrogena and Oil of Olay are some of the most effective products out there.


How They Compare

In the book, “About Face: A Plastic Surgeon’s 4-Step Nonsurgical Program for Younger, Beautiful Skin” (2005), Dr. Gregory Brown says he prefers to use non-soap cleansers such as Oil of Olay and Neutrogena on the body. When asked about the face, again Dr. Brown says that good brands are Neutrogena and Oil of Olay. The ph-balanced cleansers that Neutrogena and Oil of Olay offer are sensitive on the skin.


Daily Moisturizers With Sunscreen

One of the most important beauty routines is to apply sunscreen to your face, neck and hands. Moisturizing can be a one-step process if it already contains sunscreen. Neutrogena makes moisturizing sunscreens up to SPF 70. Olay has an Age Defying Protective Renewal Lotion with an SPF up to 30.


Nighttime Moisturizers

Dr. Brown applauds brands like Clinique, Neutrogena, Oil of Olay and Shiseido. While Clinique and Shiseido are department store brands, and, in the case of Shiseido, cost nearly three times the price, drugstore brands are still mentioned as effective. Dr. Brown claims that all of these brands are mild yet very effective.


Skin Issues: Acne

In the book “Healing Adult Acne: Your Guide to Clear Skin and Self-Confidence”, Fried (2005) states that for dry and combination skin, both Neutrogena and Oil of Olay are excellent choices. For oily skin, Fried suggests using Neutrogena Oil-Free Acne Wash.

People who suffer from acne generally need some form of topical treatment. Fried suggests Neutrogena Advanced Solutions Acne Treatment and Neutrogena Rapid Clear Acne Eliminating gel.


In a Nutshell

Neutrogena and Oil of Olay rate about the same when it comes to the opinion of a plastic surgeon. He maintains that ritual is almost as important as what you put on your skin.

You should be cleansing every day and applying a sunscreen every day. He states in his book, “Look for inexpensive brands, or stick to the new clear zinc oxides” (Brown, 2005).


The Bottom Line

Drugstores brands are as good as department store brands when it comes down to it. The important factors are to cleanse, moisturize and use sunscreen on a daily basis. Have a ritual that includes cleansing, toning, moisturizing and — most importantly — sunscreen. Whether it’s Oil of Olay or Neutrogena, both have solidified their place in the market as good brands that do their job.


A Social Conscience

Fried (2005) points out that companies like Neutrogena embrace societal excitement for herbal products — using ingredients like soy, chamomile, green tea extract and DMAE.