Crème fraiche is a thickened cream product made by allowing bacteria to sour heavy cream. Its flavor is somewhat similar to that of sour cream, but it has a slightly different consistency (somewhat like a very soft cheese) and a less tangy flavor. If you do not need crème fraiche for several days, you can make your own by mixing 1 to 2 tbsp. of buttermilk with 1 cup of whipping cream. Heat this mixture until it is just barely warm to the touch. Store it in a covered (but not airtight) container at warm room temperature for 24 to 36 hours, then refrigerate for up to 10 days. If you need an immediate crème fraiche substitute, use sour cream.
Things You'll Need
Measure out an amount of sour cream equal to the amount of crème fraiche called for in your recipe.
Add the sour cream to the recipe at the same time and in the same manner as you would have added the crème fraiche.
Reduce the heat if your dish including the sour cream ever approaches a boil. Crème fraiche is significantly better at handling high temperatures than sour cream, which can curdle if it reaches a boil. Maintain the heat at a gentle simmer (at most) when substituting sour cream for crème fraiche.
Add a small amount of cream or milk to sour cream (approximately 1 tbsp. per cup of sour cream) if your recipe calls for you to drizzle the crème fraiche over something. Stir thoroughly to blend the cream or milk into the sour cream and to give the sour cream a texture that will allow it to be drizzled more easily.
You can make a crème fraiche substitute with sour cream rather than buttermilk. Mix equal portions of sour cream and heavy whipping cream, then cover lightly and allow to stand at room temperature for approximately eight hours before using in lieu of crème fraiche.
References and ResourcesEasy French Food: Creme Fraiche Recipe
OChef: On the Trail of Creme Fraiche
Practically Edible: Creme Fraiche
JoyofBaking.com: Creme Fraiche Recipe