How Can You Tell Real Emeralds?

By Lauren Whitney

An emerald is the brilliant green version of the gemstone beryl. People have prized these vivid gems since antiquity. On Pliny's advice, the Roman emperor Nero commissioned the shaping of an exceptionally clear emerald through which the ruler could "refresh and restore" his sight as he watched gladiators in combat. Modern emerald aficionados can choose a number of less expensive alternatives to the precious gemstone, but first they must be able to spot a genuine emerald. A jeweler first determines the authenticity of the emerald, then ascertains whether the gem is natural or lab-created.

emerald
credit: Dzmitry Sukhavarau/Hemera/Getty Images
A genuine emerald has a distinctive shade of green.

Video of the Day

Identifying Genuine Emerald

Gold jewerly.
credit: Mirela Schenk/iStock/Getty Images
Emerald and diamond jewelry, close-up

Step 1

Look at the stone's color. Both natural and lab-created emeralds range in hue from a pale but vivid green to a deep true green. Stones with a distinct yellowish or chartreuse cast are not emeralds, but are most likely peridots or green garnets.

Oscar clothes
credit: Frazer Harrison/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images
Emerald ring

Step 2

Note any fire that the gem displays. Fire, or what gemologists term as dispersion, refers to the scintillant (flashes of light) spectral hues that a stone shows under white light. Diamonds, for example, have a good deal of fire. Natural emeralds have low dispersion and should show little fire. Flashy green gems are probably cubic zirconia.

83rd Annual Academy Awards - Arrivals
credit: John Shearer/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images
Emerald and diamond bracelet on woman's hand

Step 3

Examine the stone edge as well as the top facet to spot a doublet. Manufacturers can sandwich a thin layer of paler emerald between pieces of cut glass using deep green epoxy to mimic a higher-quality emerald. Looking at the gem's sides reveals the layers to detect these fake stones.

Step 4

Look at the stone through a jeweler's loupe. If the edges of the facets seem worn, the stone is probably not a genuine emerald, but is emerald-colored glass. Natural and lab-created emeralds have a hardness of 7.5 to 8 on the Mohs scale, higher than that of glass. (A diamond is a 10.) Relatively soft glass has a hardness of 5.5 and loses its sharp edge quickly with time and use.

Identifying Natural Emerald

Harry Winston Unveils Their Red Carpet Oscar Collection
credit: Frazer Harrison/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images
Emerald Jewelry

Step 5

Note the price of the gem. Although natural emeralds and lab-created emeralds contain the same constituent elements, naturally formed stones cost hundreds or thousands of dollars per carat, depending on clarity and color.

Emerald Jewel
credit: Travis Manley/Hemera/Getty Images
Emerald jewel

Step 6

Examine the gem with unaided eyes. Natural emerald stones frequently contain inclusions of liquid, gas or mineral solids that give the gem a cloudy or dusty appearance. Larger emeralds are less likely to exhibit good clarity.

Green emerald gem on a golden background with copy space
credit: LVV/iStock/Getty Images
Green emerald gem

Step 7

Compare the gem's color to others, if possible. Lab-created emeralds uniformly exhibit the vivid green hue that jewelers prize most in natural emeralds, while naturally formed emeralds vary in color. If a given stone matches others in the jewelry case perfectly, it is probably lab created.

Step 8

Look at the stone through a jeweler's loupe to examine its inclusions. Jewelers have a term for the unique pattern of inclusions that each stone contains, called the emerald's jardin, from the French word garden. Each stone's jardin of bubbles, feathers and fissures is as unique as a fingerprint, and only natural emeralds feature a jardin.